“Wine doesn’t smell like bleach,” I whispered. His eyes sparked with something harsh and icy. He said, “Trust me, Amelia,” quietly.
“You really don’t want the details.”
I was chilled by the words. He went unusually early the next morning, muttering about a meeting. His goodbye kiss was impersonal.
I stared at my coffee at the kitchen table, repeating the night before until my nerves were raw. My patience ran out by midmorning. I checked the basement again.
Locked door. The basement door had never been secured in my house, even before Daniel moved in. I forgot we had a key.
No one knew the house better than me. I was shown every secret by my grandmother. Include the extra key wrapped in fabric and tied with a rubber band behind the old boiler.
Daniel must have been unaware. My hands shook as I unlocked the basement with the key. Bleach lingered, albeit faintly.
The concrete stain was lighter but still noticeable, a ghost trace. I noticed the trash bag. I walked slowly, reverberating in the solitude.
Kneeling, I untied the plastic tie and looked in. Heart fell. It wasn’t carpet padding.
Not cleaning cloths. It was apparel. On top was a lovely, expensive-looking white summer dress with thin straps and a flowing skirt.
One of Daniel’s favorite formal shirts underneath. Deep, blotchy stains covered both. At one scary moment, my thoughts went to the deadliest conclusion.
After leaning closer, I breathed. Wine. Sour red wine for cheap.
The stink was obvious. The questions kept coming to me like bricks. Why was a woman’s dress in my basement?
Why was Daniel rushing to clean? Why did he lock the door afterward? I needed answers.
The only person I trusted with them was our neighbor Mrs. Callahan. She was razor-sharp in her late 70s and could observe anything on our block.
Some called her nosy. I found her useful. Still holding the dress, I went next door.
She smiled and opened the door quickly. “Amelia, dear! Already back from Chicago?
I answered, “Yes,” trying to seem calm. “Did you notice anyone visiting our house while I was away?”
Her eyes sparkled at being asked. “Ah yes.
I observed Daniel coming home with a young woman Friday night while watering my petunias. Nice little creature, probably late 20s. She wore a white outfit like yours.”
The blood left my face.
“They went inside around seven,” Mrs. Callahan said. I didn’t see her go.
Her car was in the driveway when I went to bed.”
I only needed that message. The image in my head was vivid and sickening. When Daniel arrived home that night, happy as ever, I confronted him at the kitchen table.
“I know everything,” I answered quietly but steadily. His smile sank. “You mean what?”
“I returned to the basement today.
Saw the dress. Daniel, Mrs. Callahan saw her.
She observed you bring a woman home Friday night when I was away.”
The panic on his face was obvious. He hid his head in his hands. He said, “Okay,” finally.
“Yes. I brought someone. But not what you think.”
He identified Sophie as his officemate.
They intended to review materials as she mentored him for a promotion. “She brought a bottle of wine,” Daniel said hastily. “We searched my files downstairs.
Wine splattered when she slid while reaching. Both of us got it. So my shirt and her outfit were stained.
She took one of your gowns to wear home because she was ashamed. Cleanup was my goal before you returned. I panicked when you found me.”
It made sense.
Overly plausible. “Then call her,” I commanded. “I want her direct response.”
He hesitated briefly before nodding.
Sophie joined us at a modest Italian restaurant the next night. She was elegant, confident, and stunning. Most critically, her account matched Daniel’s.
She apologized for the embarrassment, said Daniel was professional, and that he always talked about me. “He clearly adores you,” she replied ruefully while smiling. My boundaries should have been clearer.
We’ll keep our relationship professional going forward.”
After the night, I almost felt sorry for my doubts. Sophie seemed genuine. Everything she said matched Daniel’s tale.
But as Daniel and I sat on our silent couch later, I still felt uneasy. “Daniel,” I whispered, “if anything like this happens again—anything that makes me doubt what I believe about us—I won’t be able to give you the benefit of the doubt again. I can’t keep breaking and fixing my trust.”
He nodded seriously, drawing me in.
“I understand fully. I guarantee this will never happen again.”
To believe him. Unsure whether I do.
